Opposites Don’t Always Attract: When to Run for the Hills

by Ellen Nordahl on April 7, 2010

I’m no stranger to the old adage “opposites attract” – looking back on some of my past relationships leaves me wondering exactly how I ever managed to date someone so dissimilar from myself.  There’s a certain novelty to being in a relationship with someone who challenges your status quo, and sometimes, finding a yin to your yang really can balance you out.

While some differences can be worked through – religion, political beliefs, cultural norms – some are deal breakers, and in my experience, being in college can delay their appearance.  One that is all too easily masked until you’re in the real world is personal initiative (or self-motivation, if you like).

It may initially sound counter-intuitive, but college provides a series of already-defined tasks that don’t necessarily require a tremendous level of personal initiative to progress through.  But, what happens when that system is no longer in place, and you (and your partner) are left to your own devices to determine what comes next?  What happens when you’re dedicating yourself to preparing for a successful career and your partner decides to postpone the job hunt, and suddenly displays a completely indifferent attitude toward beginning the post-collegiate life?

Well, if you’re anything like me, you assume that should you lend some support and encouragement, your somewhat overdeveloped sense of personal initiative will be catching.

In all likelihood, you will be wrong…and one of two things will happen:

1.  You will smother and alienate your partner with unwanted information. Erika Lawrence, an associate professor of psychology in the UI College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, recently conducted research regarding the support couples give one another.  She found that “too much informational support — usually in the form of unwanted advice-giving — is the most detrimental” to a relationship – more so than not providing enough support.  When you bombard your significant other with job postings or suggestions as to things he or she could do to “step up” an area of their life that is lacking in your opinion, you’re not doing anyone any favors…yourself included.

2.  You will enable your partner to become dependent on you as an external source of motivation…which is fine, until you decide to stop being a full-time cheerleader and to invest that energy elsewhere.  Psychology Today’s Jeremy Sherman recently pointed out that unlike humans, other mammals don’t require an external source of Vitamin C.  Apparently, we have the genes required to self-produce Vitamin C, but they’re “damaged beyond functionality.”   As our ancestors incorporated fruit into their diets (and in the process got Vitamin C), the dual sources of the vitamin resulted in what is coined “lazy gene theory.”  Once fruit was readily available, our Vitamin C genes “had no effect on survival” and “just accumulated errors until they didn’t work…And now we’re addicted to this external source of C. Our dependency on it constrains and shapes our behavior.”

If their personal initiative was never there to begin with, what happens when you stop bending over backward and accept that it’s not your responsibility?  If your over-involvement hasn’t already resulted in your partner’s resentment, you’ll begin to resent having to pony up motivation for two.

My (slightly embarrassing) case in point: I briefly dated a home-schooled, Frisbee-golfing waiter who worked at a Thai restaurant and was raised on a miniature donkey farm.  He had no desire to go to college and completely lacked a direction in life – something that didn’t bother him in the slightest (and drove me up a wall).   While it was thankfully a short-lived relationship, had I considered the fundamental difference in our ambitions and levels of self-motivation, I wouldn’t have given him the time of day.

Zero personal initiative combined with excessive personal initiative doesn’t “average out.”

  • I used to seek someone who possesses traits I lack: socializing, gung-ho attitude, and upbeat personality. I thought I was looking for someone who was opposite of me, so that we could compliment each other. Now I know better - I was hoping my significant other could fill the void in my life and "complete me." There was no space for how much I can give to my other half.

    I now think as long as we recognizes a relationship is about how much we can bring to one another, not take, then the personality difference might not be that important. Certainly, I hope I live that way.
  • EllenNordahl
    Thanks for reading and commenting, Isao! You raise an excellent point about looking to a partner for a sense of completion, instead of just seeking out those who bring out the best in you. I love what you said about thinking of a relationship in terms of what you BRING to the other person, not what you hope to take away from them - when you're together with someone who also has that attitude, you both stand to gain instead of having one partner drain the energy/resources of the other.
  • Haleybop
    I have found (after being an oblivious "dutiful" wife/sugar mama for 6 years) that people who don't have any internal drive to succeed for themselves and for the betterment of their loved ones will not change. When I got sick last summer and was unable to work, my husband (now ex-husband) decided that I wasn't footing the bill anymore and he decided that he needed to move on to another girl and ask for a divorce right after I was discharged from the hospital. I have learned that I will never be with another person that I wouldn't hire as an employee in my company. There is a lot to be said for loyalty, hard work, teamwork, and customer/people service/hospitality. I may be jaded right now, but I know that I know that your statement is true.....it definately does not average out.
    Another great post Ellen, I love reading them!
  • EllenNordahl
    I do believe that people can change...but they have to find the willpower to do so from somewhere inside of themselves, and not everyone has the capacity or the strength to undertake such a daunting task. I think that a partner can make a conscious decision to change for you, but you can't change them for you.

    No relationship is a 50/50 split, but you need to find someone who is willing to carry 70% when you only have the capacity to hold up 30....and vise versa. I know for you, carrying you ex-husband's burden never required a second's hesitation - you did it freely and with love. The problem arises when that behavior is never reciprocated...not only are you supposed to motivate yourself through the hard times, but you're strapped with their baggage as well.
  • carlymarion
    I could not agree more with the importance of your significant other being able to find the motivation within themselves. I have always given my significant others the benefit of the doubt in this respect, but have been left disappointed and subsequently alone (by my choice). I am making it a point to pay mind to this before diving into my next relationship, whenever that presents itself. I need an equal; NOT a project, NOT a warm body. And its gonna be great when I do! Great post Elle.
  • EllenNordahl
    You and me both - we'll have to hold each other accountable on this one. It seems like it doesn't matter how much potential you see in someone else if they refuse to see it in themselves - it's an exercise in futility and it's exhausting.
  • jchewitt
    This is such a complicated issue that I'm not sure where to even begin. What's worked the best for me is to be willing to spend a lot of time single to work things out. I went through most of HS and college in relationships - it took a while to adjust to just being alone, to break the patterns of previous liaisons.

    I've also learned to avoid writing about former romantic partners in public - not intended as a criticism of you or this post - but I just wanted to share my experience. I know a lot of female writers make it a habit to write about ex-boyfriends (I've written about girlfriends too, sparingly), but it can have a chilling effect on future relationships. You want to allow partners to feel safe to take risks, be honest, and be vulnerable.

    Even if you don't use their name, their friends will know who you're writing about. It can be unpleasant and intimidating.

    If they think they could be the topic of a blog post in the future, it's going to spook them.
  • EllenNordahl
    Thanks for sharing your experience. I did put a lot of thought into going through with publishing this post - it had been sitting in my drafts folder for a few weeks. My "case in point" ex-boyfriend is someone that I haven't seen or talked to in 3 1/2 years, and we had only one mutual friend.

    I felt like I couldn't write a post like this without relaying some of my own personal experience in the matter - I'm far from perfect (I played the role of the supportive information overload girlfriend and have since learned my lesson). I'm also not one to air dirty laundry in a public forum - nothing I wrote here is anything that hasn't been discussed numerous times before with my friends and former boyfriend.

    I don't intend to make relationship-focused posts a regular topic here, but in being single for nearly a year, I've come to realize that a major factor in the failure of my previous relationships has been a disconnect between my personal motivation and my partner's...and felt it was worth pointing out to other readers.

    That said, I'll keep your advice in mind, and appreciate your feedback.
  • jchewitt
    Yup, this is a learning process, and I'm mostly speaking from my own experience in this - and my recent thoughts. If you write for an audience, you're in a position of considerable power.

    The question I think is most healthy to ask when evaluating a bad relationship is... "Why did I choose this person? If I picked someone like that, what does it tell me about my personality?" Maybe it could've shown that you were looking to get an outlet for a part of your personality that *isn't* career-driven, that's doesn't mind a few mini-asses. Dating the waiter probably wasn't the best way to do that, of course, but you can still learn from the mistake.

    It's important to write about relationships, and I certainly learned a lot from doing so in the past.

    Most other problems are really relationship problems masquerading as other issues. When people complain about debt, career, or personal finance issues, for example, it's usually some kind of relationship problem at the core.
  • EllenNordahl
    Mini-asses - a well-played remark. You're right - I was looking for someone to balance me out and take my mind away from focusing on my career and the future. He was always able to live in the present, and as much as that could drive me nuts, it made me realize that it's important to appreciate the here and the now for what it is.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: