The Great Paradox: Vulnerability and True Happiness

by Ellen Nordahl on April 12, 2010

At this time last year, I was a month away from graduating and should have felt on top of the world.  In reality, I was terribly lonely, unhappy, and scared out of my wits about the future…and I’d fallen out of touch with everyone who could relate to what I was experiencing.  I had managed to completely tie my sense of self-worth to leaving college with a full-time job offer, and had put all of my relationships on the back-burner.  When that didn’t pan out the way I’d planned, I was crushed.

Fast-forward to now: my mom is no longer the only person to call me on a regular basis.  I’ve reconnected with the friends who bring out the best in me and make me grateful to be alive.  I’ve branched out, taken risks I’d never imagined actually taking, and have met some wonderful new friends along the way.  And, lo and behold, I’m starting a new full-time job in May.

The one factor responsible for my turn-around?

Trust.  Trust in myself, and in others.

According to psychoanalyst Erik Erikson, our disposition to trust (or mistrust) others is formulated during the first 18 months of our life.  His theory holds that “If we pass successfully through this period of life, we will learn to trust that life is basically okay and have basic confidence in the future. If we fail to experience trust and are constantly frustrated because our needs are not met, we may end up with a deep-seated feeling of worthlessness and a mistrust of the world in general.”

While this stage of our development may create a filter through which all of our subsequent experiences pass, it does not damn us to a life of foolishly trusting others or keeping them needlessly at bay.  We just need to keep this predisposition in mind as we evaluate our relationships with others.

Trusting others had come easily and naturally for me until an awful party during the middle of my collegiate experience.  After that night, I began attributing the trust-destroying acts of others to some inherent flaw in myself, and questioned my ability to judge the trustworthiness of others.  Eventually, I became so focused on removing the potential for future hurt and disappointment that my mistrust prevented me not only from reconnecting with the people I sorely missed (and still trusted), but also from forming new relationships.

Knowing that I had gotten myself into this situation, I finally stopped waiting for everyone else to reach out to me.

It’s frightening to re-establish the lines of communication with friends you’ve been out of touch with – especially if, like me, your tendency toward isolation in the face of challenging circumstances caused the schism in the relationship to begin with.  Reconnecting with these individuals gave me the courage to reach out and begin to establish new friendships, which could flourish should I continue to allow myself to trust.

This hasn’t happened over night, nor has it been easy, but when I think that I might have missed out so many fulfilling relationships because of the painful actions of a few, the hurt pales in comparison to the joys that have come as a direct result of trusting others.

Find a balance (though it’s easier said than done).  You don’t need expose your deepest vulnerabilities to every person you meet – remember there is such a thing as TMI.  But, if the barrier you’ve erected makes the Berlin Wall seem like a picket fence, perhaps you need to reevaluate the mental fortifications you’ve made over the years.  Detachment as a defense mechanism is a recipe for unhappiness.

“We’re never so vulnerable than when we trust someone—but paradoxically, if we cannot trust, neither can we find love or joy.” – Walter Anderson

Do you bestow a certain implicit level of trust to new people in your life, or do you expect them to start at zero and prove their trustworthiness over time?

  • I had spent a long time believing that I was trusting others who regularly "betrayed" me. Now I know better; I wasn't trusting anyone, I was merely following others or blindly accepting their opinions. I think we must first learn to trust ourselves, and only then we can truly trust others: because we can't do so unless we have faith in our decisions, including taking responsibility when things do not turn out as we hoped.
  • Great post. I think of trust as very much related to empathy and empowerment. When we can relate to someone's experience it's easier to trust them because they seem much more predictable. It's when people surprise us and we start to doubt their intentions that distrust arises. So, for me, a big question has been -- how do I always see other people's intentions as saying something about them, not about me? In other words, how do I reframe any specific encounter from one in which I am a victim to one in which I am always free to respond?

    With this mindset, over many, many years, I've been able to drop a lot of my defenses. What am I defending against anyway? Because I see other people's behaviors and actions as reflective of what they want, and I can identify with where they're coming from, I don't have anything to defend. Like you said, it's the connection between vulnerability and happiness. When there is no image to maintain, when we're completely vulnerable, there is nothing getting in the way of an expressive and free way of being.

    I give you credit for the courage to post this and to raise these issues!


  • Kathryn_Smith
    I didn't want to respond directly on Brazen because this is a personal issue for me. Thanks for the post. I am graduating in May, and I am where you were at that point. My trust-misplacement issue happened mid-high school and I've still not fully recovered. I have some people around me who reinforce that I am the problem - I misjudge character and put myself in bad situations. So I always hold people at arm's length... or further. It's a lonely road.
  • you're not the problem. it is not your fault that people let you down. If the pattern keeps repeating itself then of course you're gonna have issues! If people are telling you that you're a problem then they are not helping you, they are just making you feel worse and giving you more reason to keep people at a distance; thinking that if it's YOU then the only way to fix it is to keep people behind the fence. If you have just one friend that you can confide in that should help you move towards trust again. Find that person and let them know how much you value them.
  • EllenNordahl
    Thanks for sharing this, Kathryn. My trust issues affected me profoundly until I decided to go talk to someone about what led to their development and how to move past the barrier they were creating in my life. It was not an easy decision as it tends to be hard for me to accept help from anyone, let alone ask for it. That said, I found a wonderful counselor through my school's health system and she really helped me come to terms with the things that had happened to me - and realize that I didn't have to let those issues constrain my future. Feeling alone and unable to connect with others is one of the most wretched feelings I've ever experienced...but I realized that it's not a fate you're doomed to forever. I hope you can find people who support you and will allow you to slowly but surely re-establish lines of trust.
  • I've always made friends slowly, not because I didn't trust them, I trust people a lot (too much apparently), but because I'm slow to warm up to people. I thought that maybe this slow process would naturally fix that trust issue and let me know who I can trust and who I can't. It seems to work because if we end up forming a friendship then the trust is there. If we don't become that great of friends then the trust isn't there.

    I think I've tried to strike a balance, but like you I recently had a situation where people who I had trusted completely turned their backs on me and then subsequently stabbed me in the back when I wasn't looking. I reprimand myself, telling myself that I should've known! Until know I had never had a friend so intentionally hurt me after being there for me and even offering me a place to live. I was shocked that someone who I had trusted so completely could do that to me.

    This post is quite timely for I just posted this in my own blog and it's along the same lines of friendship:
    http://rummaged-and-ransacked....

    I guess stuff like this just happens and you just have to move on and remember that not everyone is like that. You don't have to stop trusting people because of a few bad apples.
  • EllenNordahl
    I just read (and commented on) your post - funny how many of us have been in such similar situations. It's really a shock to the system when someone you trusted implicitly turns around and completely betrays you. It's hard to open up again and expose yourself to the possibility of feeling that pain after you've experienced being thrown under the bus by someone you held in high regard.
  • katethegr8
    First off I would like to admit I have a wall (or maybe more of a mini picket fence?) and I think this has a direct correlation with of course past experiences but also first impressions. First impressions are always seared into my mind when it comes to meeting new people. I know that we have tons of research at our finger tips concluding we size people up in seconds and as much that I am aware of this I can’t stop judging sometimes. (Bad Kitty) For me people can say a sentence with poor grammar or chew with their mouths open and sheeebang, ladies and gentleman I may have written them off or found a new nick name for them. Whereas sometimes “they can be the thorns leading up to the rose”- as my savvy entrepreneurial mother would say. My mother’s thought is becoming clearer as I’ve submerged myself in the corporate world along with the challenge of not knowing anyone in a new city.
    In the past I have given trust to those immediately and after much trail and error that has left me with a handful of trustworthy friends who I am grateful for. Opening my trust windows to everyone hasn’t paid off quite yet with my laundry list of relationship casualties, but on the other hand just like your closing quote, I wouldn’t have found love without my windows wide open. I think for me, my x-friends and people in general continue to disregard loyalty and appreciation for me and the friendship I come with…it is a nice package I think.  Maybe when I put loyalty high on my list of priorities I shouldn’t assume others operate like me to avoid the failed friendship feeling. In short, I have revamped my trust tank and have been cautiously peeling back my layers like an onion for those who appear loyal and deserving of my trust. But I can’t help but concluding no matter what we put in or how open we are sometimes it appears inevitable that no matter what, some people will fail us. Thank heavens for the wonderful loving few who can fill our trust bucket back up after those blows.


    Great post!
  • EllenNordahl
    It's so hard to strike a balance in revealing yourself/trusting another in the process of getting to know someone. You don't want to overwhelm them, but you don't want to make them wade through the Fireswamp and back just to get a taste of genuine, authentic you. For me, it's been important to remember that try as I might, I'm not a perfect friend - we all have our shortcomings and disappoint the people we love. What's most important is that you take the steps to right the wrong, learn from it and move on. Some people won't learn and won't put the effort into maintaining a strong friendship, and we have to make peace with letting them go.
  • Ohhh, I absolutely love that Walter Anderson quote. LOVE it.

    It reminds me of this quote from Jane Green that I just tumbled: "It’s all well and good saying you avoid pain by avoiding relationships, but what about the wonderful things you’re avoiding as well? What about the joy and the intimacy and the trust that come with finding someone you love?"

    Where are you starting a job in May?! This is so exciting, I'm so happy for you.

    Also, this is a beautifully poignant post. I love it.
  • EllenNordahl
    That is an awesome quote; I'm going to have to add it to my collection. It's a huge risk to make yourself vulnerable to someone else, but when it's reciprocated, it's the most rewarding kind of risk you can ever hope to take.

    I've decided to stay in Wisconsin for the time being and accepted a job with Epic Systems - they're a healthcare/medical records technology company located here in Madison.

    Your compliment on my writing means so much to me - small things like that make my day :)
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: